Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gavin Pugh's avatar

This seems tangentially related, and I think it's less of a problem now than is it was 5 years ago (or maybe I've just sufficiently changed my community affiliations), but I'm going to bring it up anyways.

One thing that frustrates me is the expansion of the term "gaslighting" to encompass any instance of someone disagreeing with your interpretation of events. But, like, it's not gaslighting if I honestly think you left the gaslight on. "Gaslighting," as it's meant, requires nefarious intention.

If Alice tells Bob "I can fly," Bob isn't gaslighting Alice if he says "no you can't," even if Alice ends up having some magical flying ability. Bob has every reason to think Alice is mistaken and that her mistaken belief will cause her serious harm.

But, like with "grooming," distinguishing between the nefarious and benign versions of "gaslighting" requires mind-reading, which caused people to default to "all denial of personal interpretation is equivalent to the maximally evil version."

Daniel Speyer's avatar

For me, and I suspect many others, there's an element of Control Of One's Own Life that matters separate from goodness or badness of experiences. It's especially important to explicit verbal consent, but applies throughout.

If I tell my GF "let's try pegging", or she says that and I say "ok", and it turns out to be a really painful and horrible time, then I made a mistake, suffered and learned from it. And I can move on.

If she were to try it without check in, even if she were objectively as skilled as I in predicting my reactions to experiences, that would be hard to recover from.

I realize this gets more complicated when children are involved.

13 more comments...

Ready for more?